Support Our Cause

Enter Amount:

Newsletter Subscription






Visitors Stats

mod_vvisit_countermod_vvisit_countermod_vvisit_countermod_vvisit_countermod_vvisit_countermod_vvisit_counter
mod_vvisit_counterToday29
mod_vvisit_counterYesterday106
mod_vvisit_counterThis week304
mod_vvisit_counterThis month1534
mod_vvisit_counterAll28634

Who's Online

Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.

- Margaret Mead
Mekong carries the runoff from China's superpower status PDF Print E-mail
By Michael Richardsom
Canberra Times (Australia)
1 September 2008

China says it remains a developing country despite an impressively rapid rise in the league of global power. By some measures, it is now the world's third biggest economy and second largest exporter. However gauged, China is clearly a nation with increasing impact and influence, especially if you live in nearby South-East Asia.

So it comes as no surprise that China is blamed these days for local troubles almost as ritualistically as the United States, the superpower China says it will never emulate.

 


The latest finger pointing at China comes in the wake of devastating floods in parts of northern Thailand and Laos after the Mekong, South-East Asia's largest river, overflowed its banks, inundating villages and rice fields, and leaving a swath of destruction that will cost many millions of dollars to repair.

The water level on August 15 at Vientiane, the capital of Laos on the banks of the Mekong, was the highest since records began in 1913. Although it has dropped since then, low-lying regions in Cambodia and the Mekong Delta of southern Vietnam are bracing themselves for similar damage as the floodwaters move downstream.

Some Thais hit by the floods, as well as non-governmental organisations campaigning against dam building, say that water released from the reservoirs of three big Chinese dams on the upper reaches of the Mekong swelled the runoff from a tropical storm and heavy monsoon rain across northern Laos and China's southern Yunnan Province early last month.

But the Mekong River Commission, in a statement last week, pointed out that the volume of releasable water held by the three Chinese hydro-power dams to generate electricity was too small to have been a significant factor in the flooding. The commission, established by the governments of Cambodia, Laos, Thailand and Vietnam in 1995 at the end of a long period of conflict in the region, helps to coordinate management of the Mekong Basin in South-East Asia.

As the world's 12th longest river, the Mekong runs through or between six countries China, Burma and the four commission member states. Although the Mekong starts high in China's Qinghai-Tibetan plateau and flows through China for more than one-third of its total length of over 4300km, China is not a commission member.

Nor is reclusive Burma. They are ''dialogue partners'' who meet commission members from time to time and share only some information about their respective sections of the river.

The commission says that the combined storage capacity of the three Chinese dams on the upper section of the Mekong is less than one cubic kilometre. It adds that only a small part of this could have been released as the floodwaters in the area accumulated between August 8, when the tropical storm struck, and August 12, when the flood peak in the Mekong was measured at Chiang Saen, in Thailand, where the commission has its most northerly monitoring station.

At Chiang Saen on that day, measurements showed an accumulated flood runoff volume for the month of 8.5 cubic kilometres, while further downsteam at Vientiane on 12 August it was 23 cubic kilometres, leading the commission to conclude that any release from the Chinese dams ''could not have been a significant factor in this natural flood event''.

While this may be true, Chinese dam construction on the upper reaches of the Mekong is a legitimate source of concern for downstream South-East Asian countries. To generate electricity, water has to be released to drive the turbines.

Their worry is that too much will be released in the wet season, contributing to flooding, and too little in the dry season, when the water is needed in South-East Asia.

This concern will be accentuated when China completes the fourth dam on its section of the Mekong by 2013.

This dam at Xiaowan will be 292m high, one of the world's tallest. It will generate over 4000 megawatts of electricity, the equivalent output of at least four nuclear power stations.

Its reservoir will impound water in a 190sqkm reservoir that Chinese officials say will hold 15 billion cubic metres of water, nearly five times the volume held by the three existing dams.

They say this will reduce the amount of water flowing into South-East Asia by 17 per cent during the flood season and increase the flow by 40 per cent in the dry season.

Four more dams are planned for the Mekong in Yunnan, one of which will have a storage capacity similar to Xiaowan. Just filling the Xiaowan dam's reservoir is estimated to take between five and 10 years, using half the upper Mekong's flow. Clearly, a cascade of dams on this scale will affect the amount and quality of water available to downstream states in South-East Asia.

Averaged over the year, only about 20 per cent of the water flowing into the lower section of the Mekong comes from China. However, Chinese policy is particularly important in the dry season, when the long stretch of the Mekong on its territory accounts for 50 per cent to 70 per cent of the water flow at the mouth of river in Vietnam, where it meets the South China Sea.

If China is serious when it promises a cooperative and mutually beneficial partnership with South-East Asia, it should join the Mekong River Commission as a full member, share all hydrological information with its neighbours and integrate its Yunnan dam planning into the development blueprint for the lower Mekong Basin.

This would strengthen commission efforts to develop and apply an integrated management plan for the whole of the Mekong River Basin, with multilateral as well as national interests in mind.

The writer, a former Asia editor of the International Herald Tribune, is an energy and security specialist at the Institute of South-East Asian Studies in Singapore.

Comments
Add New RSS
Tony   |09-02-2008 05:51:32
Oh man, there's going to be a total of 8 dams built by the Chinese for the Mekong. There goes the livelihood of 60 million people living in the area of the river.
mao   |09-02-2008 15:25:03
you ain't see nothin yet, There will a series of Dams on the red river also, which runs through hanoi, and empty to gulf of tonkins.
banananut   |09-02-2008 16:45:13
I wonder if this is a malicious idea of hurting its neighbors as a way to show its "power", or a bad planning to punish their own people. If earthquake happens in this region, who will be the ones who worry about being dry?
Mao's concubine   |09-02-2008 19:52:57
Mao has been here and his purpose is to show to everyone that he and his China are fond of hurting people and destroying the ecological world.

This life goes around comes around and those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
Mao   |09-02-2008 20:26:02
Are you folks aware that in Cambodia and Laos, they are buuilding Dams there themselves to solve the electricity problem.

So you looking a combined of more than 12 to 13 Dams along the Mekong before the water arrive Vietnam..LOL
Tony   |09-02-2008 22:12:21
Yes, it is true that dams are being built by Laos, Cambodia and Thailand. And objectively speaking, these will have an effect on the Mekong River in a negative way. However, these countries have a cooperative relationship with one another in which they will most be likely to work together in order to minimize the negative effects. However, the relationship between China and the rest of SEA is PREDATORY. That is why China will not care much about what happens to others as long as it gets what it wants. So I don't worry about the dams in SEA as much as I worry about the 8 dams in China. Anyways, at least you are honest about China's real nature. Just can't stand the Chinese officials and people who keep saying crap like "Peaceful rise" to us. It's annoying.
mao   |09-02-2008 22:45:33
You have to understand all water origniate from inside China. It's a gift to all your folks. Don't take it for granted. China can take all this water away. now, she's being generous to you folks.
Tony   |09-03-2008 06:15:02
Mao, you're hilarious. Next, you're going to tell me that the Chinese built the Himalayas themselves, aren't you?
mao   |09-03-2008 07:53:43
There is this great South to North water project going on, which essentially channel the water resource from South to northern part of China.
THe dry north needs to the water to grow. China can control how much water you receive, practically.

this water policy will ensure cooperation among CHina and the countries lying South.

All countries are cooperating /w CHina except Vietnam, I like to see how you folks can fight when China is controlling the availability of your water resource.

If CHina limit the water out, Laos and Cmabodia would also limit their in their Dams for drinking and farming.

The last one Vietnam will receie very little flow.

Man, I love this. I love it when our enemy is fighting hard when we control their water resource
Tony   |09-04-2008 03:44:02
You may think your government is doing all of this for your people's good. But think again. Just check out this article to see what damages your own country may be suffering from your own government's actions:
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=chinas-three-gorges-dam-disaster

Perhaps you wouldn't be laughing so gleefully as you are now.
banananut   |09-03-2008 21:56:31
Oh wow, China can even control Mother Nature and the water resource. Really? The earthquakes too????
So much for the false news that Chinese could use technology to disperse the clouds and to manipulate the weather during the Olympics, pollution existed throughout the Games despite much regulated traffic rules.

You guys can pretend to be generous this or that, but in the end, believe what you want. No one can fight Mother Nature for She is fair.
banananut   |09-03-2008 22:09:12
Don't call Vietnam your enemy because the communist government is so blindly in love with you guys. Your real enemies are the overseas Vietnamese communities all over the world and ever-rising Vietnamese nationalists. We won't go away anytime soon. We are the wake-up calls to the communist government.

It's time for the fake Chinese girlfriend to say goodbye.
mao   |09-04-2008 11:03:01
Yeah, whatever government in vietnam, communists or democratic, it doesn't matter, China is going to control water resource from now on & forth. generation after generation.. no amount of oversea political activism can change the fate of that.

good luck
china   |09-04-2008 14:49:42
blablabla, didnt you guys read the topic? china should not be blamed!
it is always a easier way to blame someone stronger and with more power! those poor south east aisan ppl always try to blame someone else for their own mistakes! if anything happens to them,they will blame china for it, oh, maybe, if someone lost his dog, go blame china, if someone got damped by GF,go blame china, well i say "fuk off", china do not deserve this, we should talk the talk and walk the walk, instead of doing wut south east aisan countries ask us to do, we do wut we pleased and no one can do anything about it.
banananut   |09-04-2008 15:11:30
China has nothing to offer and only brings its bad reputation for other Asian people, who might be mistaken for being Chinese. When was the last time you hear something nice about China? No one wants to associate with it.

china, stop cursing on public forum. Use your thinking, not your mouth as it just perpetuate your bad form as I'm not the only one who read your comments.
banananut   |09-04-2008 15:16:27
China must be a "superpower" because as powerful as the EU and US, these countries have never gotten such a bad reputation as that of China.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
:angry::0:confused::cheer:B):evil::silly::dry::lol::kiss::D:pinch:
:(:shock::X:side::):P:unsure::woohoo::huh::whistle:;):s
:!::?::idea::arrow:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.23 Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 
< Prev   Next >